[考題] 98檢事官書記官已刪文
98檢事官第四題
題目很長 僅摘錄 手機打字較難請見諒
甲持有手槍 一二審均自白
二審提示附手槍照片之鑑定報告 甲稱沒有意見
問甲得否以379第10款執為上訴第三審理由?
我自己寫是
ㄧ。符合159傳聞法則之特別規定 208準用206 實務認為得以書面為之 學說認為僅以書面未言詞報告侵害甲詰問權
二。但違反直接審理原則 惟依實務見解 當事人甲不爭執 故不得以此執為上訴第三審理由
學說則認為派生證據 有379第10款事由 可以上訴三審
三。結論都採實務見解
可是看了兩種版本擬答
都只寫違反直接審理原則
那我是審題審錯 所以答錯方向嗎
懇請指教 謝謝
--
Sent from my Android
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 123.193.88.200
→
05/30 17:40, , 1F
05/30 17:40, 1F
推
05/30 18:10, , 2F
05/30 18:10, 2F
推
05/30 19:46, , 3F
05/30 19:46, 3F
→
05/30 19:49, , 4F
05/30 19:49, 4F
推
05/30 21:14, , 5F
05/30 21:14, 5F
→
05/30 21:17, , 6F
05/30 21:17, 6F
→
05/30 21:19, , 7F
05/30 21:19, 7F
→
05/30 21:43, , 8F
05/30 21:43, 8F
→
05/30 21:44, , 9F
05/30 21:44, 9F
→
05/30 21:50, , 10F
05/30 21:50, 10F
推
05/30 21:55, , 11F
05/30 21:55, 11F
→
05/30 21:56, , 12F
05/30 21:56, 12F
→
05/30 22:05, , 13F
05/30 22:05, 13F
→
05/30 22:07, , 14F
05/30 22:07, 14F
推
05/30 22:08, , 15F
05/30 22:08, 15F
→
05/30 22:09, , 16F
05/30 22:09, 16F
推
05/30 22:10, , 17F
05/30 22:10, 17F
→
05/30 22:11, , 18F
05/30 22:11, 18F
推
05/30 22:12, , 19F
05/30 22:12, 19F
→
05/30 22:13, , 20F
05/30 22:13, 20F
→
05/30 22:14, , 21F
05/30 22:14, 21F
→
05/30 22:15, , 22F
05/30 22:15, 22F
→
05/30 22:17, , 23F
05/30 22:17, 23F
→
05/30 22:18, , 24F
05/30 22:18, 24F
→
05/30 22:18, , 25F
05/30 22:18, 25F
推
05/30 22:19, , 26F
05/30 22:19, 26F
推
05/30 22:23, , 27F
05/30 22:23, 27F
推
05/30 22:25, , 28F
05/30 22:25, 28F
→
05/30 22:28, , 29F
05/30 22:28, 29F
推
05/30 22:42, , 30F
05/30 22:42, 30F
→
05/30 22:42, , 31F
05/30 22:42, 31F
推
05/30 22:50, , 32F
05/30 22:50, 32F
→
05/30 22:50, , 33F
05/30 22:50, 33F
→
05/30 22:52, , 34F
05/30 22:52, 34F
推
05/30 22:59, , 35F
05/30 22:59, 35F
推
05/30 23:59, , 36F
05/30 23:59, 36F
推
05/31 00:02, , 37F
05/31 00:02, 37F
→
05/31 00:02, , 38F
05/31 00:02, 38F
→
10/11 22:54, , 39F
10/11 22:54, 39F