[閒聊] 超偶與星光
看了這禮拜的超偶,覺得越來越像以前精采時期的星光
淘汰回顧
惜鵝的淘汰回顧:http://tinyurl.com/pb63zo
雖然我對她還滿無感的,但看了也是很感動
好懷念星光的淘汰回顧還有拆海報
抱抱還有哭哭也很溫暖
王偉忠不是說星光是個很有人情味的節目嗎?
怎麼感覺越做越回去?
後製
這邊要稱讚一下星光,片頭都有重新製作
很用心效果也滿不錯的
超偶則是同樣片頭用了三屆
來比一下兩邊的淘汰後製
超偶:
http://tinyurl.com/q5rh2a
http://tinyurl.com/rbx6cv
http://tinyurl.com/qmo339
星光:
http://tinyurl.com/pslgtw
http://tinyurl.com/opybm4
雖然都是抄襲名模生死鬥的XDDDDD
但超偶比較用心一點,還特地去拍了一張團體照
星光就比較單調一點了
樂隊
這好像很多人都討論過了
超偶的樂隊專門接演唱會的case
星光的樂隊專門接綜藝節目的case....
在某些主題樂隊就非常重要
如快歌,星光5快歌那集就滿慘不忍睹的
徐詠琳那首表白驚悚的合聲還有背景音樂讓我印象深刻
其實樂隊真的撐不起一首歌的時候何不考慮直接用ktv伴奏?
拉拉的身騎白馬就是用自己的伴奏(嗩吶非常銷魂)
如果那首歌給阿咪樂隊來演奏應該就無法達到那種效果
資源
超3這屆感覺下重本
舞群 不用錢!
道具 不用錢!
佈景 不用錢! (惜鵝的夢裡花有漂亮佈景:http://tinyurl.com/p82kxw)
改造 不用錢! (超3有兩次大改造)
出國 不用錢! (超3去大陸香港踢館)
相較於星5常常只是在台上表演完一首歌就結束
其實對比還滿明顯
其實這些以前都是星光的優勢,為何這季都沒有了
選手
我只希望星6製作單位能用心海選了
超3這屆真的滿強的
相較於星5一開始就受限了(會唱的偶像歌手)
其實星光跟超偶兩邊都各有優缺,製作單位可以互相學習
互相競爭也互相進步,觀眾也有好節目可以看
以上皆個人感覺,不認同也歡迎噓
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.39.191.3
推
09/13 22:49, , 1F
09/13 22:49, 1F
推
09/13 22:50, , 2F
09/13 22:50, 2F
→
09/13 22:50, , 3F
09/13 22:50, 3F
推
09/13 22:51, , 4F
09/13 22:51, 4F
推
09/13 22:51, , 5F
09/13 22:51, 5F
推
09/13 22:51, , 6F
09/13 22:51, 6F
推
09/13 22:52, , 7F
09/13 22:52, 7F
→
09/13 22:53, , 8F
09/13 22:53, 8F
推
09/13 22:54, , 9F
09/13 22:54, 9F
→
09/13 22:55, , 10F
09/13 22:55, 10F
→
09/13 22:58, , 11F
09/13 22:58, 11F
推
09/13 23:00, , 12F
09/13 23:00, 12F
→
09/13 23:01, , 13F
09/13 23:01, 13F
推
09/13 23:11, , 14F
09/13 23:11, 14F
→
09/13 23:17, , 15F
09/13 23:17, 15F
推
09/13 23:22, , 16F
09/13 23:22, 16F
推
09/13 23:23, , 17F
09/13 23:23, 17F
→
09/13 23:24, , 18F
09/13 23:24, 18F
→
09/13 23:24, , 19F
09/13 23:24, 19F
→
09/13 23:25, , 20F
09/13 23:25, 20F
→
09/13 23:27, , 21F
09/13 23:27, 21F
→
09/13 23:27, , 22F
09/13 23:27, 22F
推
09/13 23:29, , 23F
09/13 23:29, 23F
→
09/13 23:29, , 24F
09/13 23:29, 24F
→
09/13 23:30, , 25F
09/13 23:30, 25F
→
09/13 23:30, , 26F
09/13 23:30, 26F
推
09/13 23:41, , 27F
09/13 23:41, 27F
→
09/13 23:42, , 28F
09/13 23:42, 28F
→
09/13 23:42, , 29F
09/13 23:42, 29F
推
09/13 23:46, , 30F
09/13 23:46, 30F
推
09/14 00:03, , 31F
09/14 00:03, 31F
推
09/14 00:04, , 32F
09/14 00:04, 32F
→
09/14 00:04, , 33F
09/14 00:04, 33F
推
09/14 00:06, , 34F
09/14 00:06, 34F
超偶踢館我喜歡這三組
哈騷客 Don't cha:http://tinyurl.com/q2dxqk
很熱鬧很好看
江耿鋒 對愛渴望:http://tinyurl.com/oxhjqy
聲音真的很棒,雖是初次上台但表現卻很沉穩
詹閔 寫一首歌:http://tinyurl.com/qge7h7
這女生聲音很乾淨很好聽
※ 編輯: bowwe1017 來自: 114.39.191.3 (09/14 00:12)
→
09/14 00:09, , 35F
09/14 00:09, 35F
推
09/14 00:10, , 36F
09/14 00:10, 36F
推
09/14 00:26, , 37F
09/14 00:26, 37F
→
09/14 00:27, , 38F
09/14 00:27, 38F
推
09/14 00:28, , 39F
09/14 00:28, 39F
→
09/14 00:29, , 40F
09/14 00:29, 40F
推
09/14 00:30, , 41F
09/14 00:30, 41F
推
09/14 00:39, , 42F
09/14 00:39, 42F
推
09/14 00:40, , 43F
09/14 00:40, 43F
→
09/14 00:45, , 44F
09/14 00:45, 44F
→
09/14 00:45, , 45F
09/14 00:45, 45F
推
09/14 00:49, , 46F
09/14 00:49, 46F
推
09/14 01:39, , 47F
09/14 01:39, 47F
→
09/14 01:41, , 48F
09/14 01:41, 48F
→
09/14 01:42, , 49F
09/14 01:42, 49F
推
09/14 02:06, , 50F
09/14 02:06, 50F
→
09/14 02:07, , 51F
09/14 02:07, 51F
推
09/14 02:23, , 52F
09/14 02:23, 52F
推
09/14 02:32, , 53F
09/14 02:32, 53F
推
09/14 02:34, , 54F
09/14 02:34, 54F
推
09/14 06:39, , 55F
09/14 06:39, 55F
推
09/14 09:17, , 56F
09/14 09:17, 56F
推
09/14 09:42, , 57F
09/14 09:42, 57F
推
09/14 10:24, , 58F
09/14 10:24, 58F
→
09/14 10:25, , 59F
09/14 10:25, 59F
推
09/14 10:45, , 60F
09/14 10:45, 60F
推
09/14 15:56, , 61F
09/14 15:56, 61F
推
09/14 17:51, , 62F
09/14 17:51, 62F
→
09/14 17:51, , 63F
09/14 17:51, 63F
推
09/14 19:02, , 64F
09/14 19:02, 64F
→
09/14 20:18, , 65F
09/14 20:18, 65F
→
09/14 20:20, , 66F
09/14 20:20, 66F
→
09/14 20:24, , 67F
09/14 20:24, 67F
推
09/17 15:16, , 68F
09/17 15:16, 68F
推
10/09 23:11, , 69F
10/09 23:11, 69F
→
01/16 18:34,
5年前
, 70F
01/16 18:34, 70F