[討論] MJ後Shaq/Kobe/TD誰的生涯成就最高?
MJ後最具代表性的球員大概是這四個Shaq/Kobe/TD/LBJ
其中LBJ還處在當打之年 生涯還沒蓋棺 因此暫不討論 其餘三人都已退休
可以討論一下MJ到LBJ之間的三位王者 誰的成就更高一些?
Shaq生涯 4*年度總冠軍 1*MVP 3*FMVP 8*第一隊
Kobe生涯 5*年度總冠軍 1*MVP 2*FMVP 11*第一隊
TD生涯 5*年度總冠軍 2*MVP 3*FMVP 10*第一隊
Shaq生涯顛峰時的主宰力最強 率領湖人三連霸 蹂躪各隊禁區
但因為受傷與保養問題導致生涯顛峰比其他兩人短 累積成就不夠 冠軍也少一個
第一隊沒破10 季賽常養生導致只有1MVP 後期在各隊遊走收集彩色戰衣
Kobe參與兩次連霸 有81分神蹟 球迷量最多 場外影響力三人之最
不過生涯最顛峰時卻是球隊最低谷(06-07) 也僅有一座mvp 打法飽受爭議
TD生涯最穩定 在隊期間都能保持50勝 五冠更橫跨99-14
不過未曾連霸是個遺憾 球風樸實低調 導致形象不如歐布鮮明 但MVP卻是三人最多
大家覺得這三人的生涯成就該怎麼排?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 60.250.201.140
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/NBA/M.1505366998.A.FB9.html
推
09/14 13:32, , 1F
09/14 13:32, 1F
推
09/14 13:32, , 2F
09/14 13:32, 2F
→
09/14 13:33, , 3F
09/14 13:33, 3F
噓
09/14 13:33, , 4F
09/14 13:33, 4F
推
09/14 13:34, , 5F
09/14 13:34, 5F
推
09/14 13:34, , 6F
09/14 13:34, 6F
→
09/14 13:34, , 7F
09/14 13:34, 7F
→
09/14 13:34, , 8F
09/14 13:34, 8F
→
09/14 13:34, , 9F
09/14 13:34, 9F
推
09/14 13:34, , 10F
09/14 13:34, 10F
推
09/14 13:34, , 11F
09/14 13:34, 11F
→
09/14 13:35, , 12F
09/14 13:35, 12F
推
09/14 13:36, , 13F
09/14 13:36, 13F
推
09/14 13:36, , 14F
09/14 13:36, 14F
→
09/14 13:36, , 15F
09/14 13:36, 15F
推
09/14 13:36, , 16F
09/14 13:36, 16F
→
09/14 13:38, , 17F
09/14 13:38, 17F
推
09/14 13:40, , 18F
09/14 13:40, 18F
推
09/14 13:40, , 19F
09/14 13:40, 19F
推
09/14 13:42, , 20F
09/14 13:42, 20F
推
09/14 13:43, , 21F
09/14 13:43, 21F
推
09/14 13:43, , 22F
09/14 13:43, 22F
推
09/14 13:43, , 23F
09/14 13:43, 23F
→
09/14 13:46, , 24F
09/14 13:46, 24F
推
09/14 13:48, , 25F
09/14 13:48, 25F
推
09/14 13:48, , 26F
09/14 13:48, 26F
→
09/14 13:48, , 27F
09/14 13:48, 27F
推
09/14 13:50, , 28F
09/14 13:50, 28F
→
09/14 13:50, , 29F
09/14 13:50, 29F
推
09/14 13:51, , 30F
09/14 13:51, 30F
推
09/14 13:51, , 31F
09/14 13:51, 31F
推
09/14 13:51, , 32F
09/14 13:51, 32F
→
09/14 13:51, , 33F
09/14 13:51, 33F
推
09/14 13:54, , 34F
09/14 13:54, 34F
推
09/14 13:54, , 35F
09/14 13:54, 35F
推
09/14 13:55, , 36F
09/14 13:55, 36F
→
09/14 13:56, , 37F
09/14 13:56, 37F
推
09/14 13:58, , 38F
09/14 13:58, 38F
→
09/14 13:58, , 39F
09/14 13:58, 39F
還有 375 則推文
→
09/15 01:43, , 415F
09/15 01:43, 415F
→
09/15 01:44, , 416F
09/15 01:44, 416F
推
09/15 01:45, , 417F
09/15 01:45, 417F
推
09/15 02:02, , 418F
09/15 02:02, 418F
推
09/15 02:07, , 419F
09/15 02:07, 419F
推
09/15 03:57, , 420F
09/15 03:57, 420F
→
09/15 03:57, , 421F
09/15 03:57, 421F
噓
09/15 04:31, , 422F
09/15 04:31, 422F
推
09/15 06:22, , 423F
09/15 06:22, 423F
→
09/15 06:23, , 424F
09/15 06:23, 424F
→
09/15 07:11, , 425F
09/15 07:11, 425F
推
09/15 07:12, , 426F
09/15 07:12, 426F
推
09/15 07:13, , 427F
09/15 07:13, 427F
→
09/15 07:13, , 428F
09/15 07:13, 428F
→
09/15 07:13, , 429F
09/15 07:13, 429F
噓
09/15 07:35, , 430F
09/15 07:35, 430F
→
09/15 07:35, , 431F
09/15 07:35, 431F
推
09/15 07:36, , 432F
09/15 07:36, 432F
推
09/15 07:47, , 433F
09/15 07:47, 433F
→
09/15 07:48, , 434F
09/15 07:48, 434F
→
09/15 08:19, , 435F
09/15 08:19, 435F
推
09/15 10:15, , 436F
09/15 10:15, 436F
→
09/15 10:19, , 437F
09/15 10:19, 437F
推
09/15 10:27, , 438F
09/15 10:27, 438F
→
09/15 10:27, , 439F
09/15 10:27, 439F
→
09/15 10:27, , 440F
09/15 10:27, 440F
推
09/15 11:03, , 441F
09/15 11:03, 441F
推
09/15 11:51, , 442F
09/15 11:51, 442F
推
09/15 13:36, , 443F
09/15 13:36, 443F
→
09/15 13:37, , 444F
09/15 13:37, 444F
→
09/15 15:17, , 445F
09/15 15:17, 445F
推
09/15 15:18, , 446F
09/15 15:18, 446F
→
09/15 16:43, , 447F
09/15 16:43, 447F
噓
09/15 16:49, , 448F
09/15 16:49, 448F
推
09/15 17:19, , 449F
09/15 17:19, 449F
→
09/15 17:19, , 450F
09/15 17:19, 450F
推
09/15 19:54, , 451F
09/15 19:54, 451F
推
09/16 02:06, , 452F
09/16 02:06, 452F
推
09/16 21:06, , 453F
09/16 21:06, 453F
推
09/17 14:59, , 454F
09/17 14:59, 454F
討論串 (同標題文章)
以下文章回應了本文:
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 6 篇):