[閒聊] Matyas Kuti
Allright, here it comes.
I already talked about this issue in an earlier post, but I have more details
now: The 2nd solve in the 15 cubes multiple blindfolded at the World
Championships 07. The video is here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hyEbkrjTeag
The part I talked about earlier is 4:00 – 4:40. He seems to mess up the
corners. And then he magically knows how to correct his mistake.
Somebody suggested that it might be an algorithm that also twists corners.
Well, I have news: I reconstructed the whole drama: from 4:00 – 5:19.
Seriously, if a person still believes that no visual aid was involved after
seeing this, he is either:
A) A person who does not know the first thing about blindfold cubing.
B) A stubborn dumbass
I have no other words to describe it. I don't see how anyone can still
believe he did not cheat after this. Here is what happened:
At 4:00, the corners are solved (after about a minute of solving).
Then he does some setup moves, a three cycle, and the inverse of the setup
moves.
Next, he uses D' L' F2 as setup moves, then a three cycle, then F2 D L!! He
inverts the moves in the wrong order, completely messing up the corners and
some edges again. Now, had he realised that he made a mistake without seeing
it, he would have just done L' D' L D to correct it. But this was clearly not
the case. Instead, he starts looking around, then starts doing the corners
all over again, including a move like z U'R'U z' to insert a yellow corner in
the first layer again, and a commutator to twist two corners.
The reconstructed part of the solve is below. I also made an applet:
http://solvethecube.110mb.com/kuti.htm
Scramble: U R2 F2 L2 U B2 D2 L2 U2 L2 U R U' D F' U F B' R' U L2 (white on
top, blue on front)
Solution:
[Three cycle] d' L D F2 R2 U R U R' U' R' U' R' U R' F2 D' L' d
[Setup moves] d2 D' L' F2
[Three cycle] M2 U M U2 M' U M2
[Wrong inverse of setup moves] F2 D L
[Looking around] y2 U U'
[Inserting D-layer corner] yz U'R'U z'y U' y'2
[J-Permutation] L' U R U' L U2 R' U R U2 R'
[Three cycle] R' x y R' R2 U R U R' U' R' U' R' U R' R y' x' R
[Twisting two corners with commutator] L2 z' U' R' U R U' R' U L' U' R U R'
U' R U L z L2 y2
[Three cycle] M' U M U2 M' U M
[Three cycle] R2 U' R' U' R U R U R U' R
[Some rotations] y2 x2 y y
[Three cycle] M' U M U2 M' U M
[Three cycle] R2 U' R' U' R U R U R U' R
[Some rotations] y' z2 y' y z2
[T-Permuatation] R y2 R U R' U' R' F R2 U' R' U' R U R' F' L'
http://tinyurl.com/2r5t7y
This video reconstruction is enough prooving that Kuti is cheating...
--
▃▄▅▇▆ █ █ ▃▄▅▆▇█ █ █ █ █
█ █ ▉ ▉ █ █ █ █ █
▉ █ ▊ ▊ ▉ ▉ ▉ ▉ █
▊ ▊▄▅▆▇▊ ▊▄▅▆▇█ ▊ ▊ ▊▊
▋ ▋ ▋ ▋ ▋ ▋ █ in
█▄▅▆▇█ ▌ ▌ ▍▄▅▆▇█ █ █ PTT.CC
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.132.84.96
推
02/23 11:08, , 1F
02/23 11:08, 1F
推
02/23 11:09, , 2F
02/23 11:09, 2F
→
02/23 11:10, , 3F
02/23 11:10, 3F
推
02/23 11:21, , 4F
02/23 11:21, 4F
→
02/23 11:21, , 5F
02/23 11:21, 5F
※ 編輯: chevylove 來自: 220.132.84.96 (02/23 11:23)
→
02/23 11:23, , 6F
02/23 11:23, 6F
推
02/23 11:38, , 7F
02/23 11:38, 7F
→
02/23 11:39, , 8F
02/23 11:39, 8F
→
02/23 11:39, , 9F
02/23 11:39, 9F
推
02/23 11:42, , 10F
02/23 11:42, 10F
在被證明有作弊或沒有作弊之前
Kuti 參加比賽也證明不了什麼,請注意這點
事實上在這篇首po之後 Kuti本來要去 Benelux Open
結果以他本人在本討論串的回文來看, Ron要他暫時不要參加比賽
但是他對於自己有沒有作弊沒有提出說明
直到這篇分析文出現,大部分的人都認為這已經足以作為證據了
在這篇出現之前,我的態度一直都是沒證據就不要把話說得太絕對
即使在一開始 Milan po 文之後我個人就覺得非常可疑了,
但是沒有絕對性的證據,任何的指控都是很不公平的.
抱歉沒有時間翻譯 , 這是 Joel 作的影片重置
他把15顆 multi 的第二顆 分析, 分析就在上面
基本上已經可以當作 Kuti 作弊的證明了抱歉沒有時間翻譯 , 這是 Joel 作的影片重置
他把15顆 multi 的第二顆 分析, 分析就在上面
基本上已經可以當作 Kuti 作弊的證明了
但 Joel 的分析足以讓我相信 Kuti 至少在這次比賽是有作弊的.
我才會 Po 文讓大家看..
關鍵點在於 Kuti 原本已經把角的方向位置都做好了
但他在作第二次換三邊的時候 , 把 setup 弄混了
導致某些角的位置跟方向又錯了,如果他在解的時候發現
只要把 setup 回復就可以
但是他卻把角又重新做了一次,用的好像是剛開始作角一樣
這就是最大的疑點以及爭論點
基本上在這篇文之前有已經很多圖片影片讓 Kuti 的嫌疑越來越大
但這個可以說是致命的一擊
※ 編輯: chevylove 來自: 220.132.84.96 (02/23 12:08)
推
02/23 12:12, , 11F
02/23 12:12, 11F
推
02/23 12:57, , 12F
02/23 12:57, 12F
推
02/23 20:51, , 13F
02/23 20:51, 13F
推
02/23 21:54, , 14F
02/23 21:54, 14F
討論串 (同標題文章)